Women's football: same on paper, different on the pitch
Enlarge image (© picture-alliance / Alfred Harder) While female footballers are playing an identical game to their male counterparts on paper, there are differences - some more visible than others - that set the women's game apart from the men's.
Comparing the physical aspects of training plans for women's and men's soccer teams in Germany would likely reveal few differences. A similar comparison of the rulebooks in women's and men's soccer would, not surprisingly, produce nearly identical results. But any soccer fan watching from the stands can see that, despite these similarities on paper, there are clear differences between the women's and men's games.
Most noticeable is the differing pace at which the games are played. Charline Hartmann, a defender for FC Cologne's women's team, says that what women lack in speed they make up for in technical ability.
"The women's game is fundamentally a bit slower," she says. "The ball is in play longer, though. With the men the game is often interrupted through fouls or aggressive play, which is not the case with the women. I think if we were as fast as the men we'd be better because we place more emphasis on technique."
While the women's game may typically be slower than the men's, it certainly isn't for lack of training. In fact, many women footballers begin their careers playing on boys teams and were often quite competitive. But at some point, says 21-year-old Cologne striker Yvonne Zielinsky, the boys start to pull away from the girls in terms of strength and speed.
"I always wanted to be faster, and for a while I could keep up," Zielinsky says. "But then there came the growth spurts, where the boys kept getting faster and eventually I couldn't keep up." Enlarge image (© picture-alliance / Augenklick / )
Differences in speed and strength between men and women on the soccer pitch can be accounted for by physiological differences between the two genders. Dr. Hans-Jürgen Tritschoks, one of the most successful women's coaches in Germany, says no matter how long or hard a woman trains, biological differences between the male and female body will always keep men a step ahead.
"It's simply because women, for the most part, are 10 to 15, and possibly 20 percent behind men in terms of things like heart volume, muscle mass or blood volume," says Tritschoks, who coached his former club, FFC Frankfurt, to the league title, the German Cup and the UEFA Women's Cup in 2008. "This, of course, has an effect which can be observed in the women's game."
A subtle touc
Markus Kühn, who coaches Zielinsky at FC Cologne, has learned some of the subtleties of coaching a women's team. While the physical aspects of his practices could be implemented on a men's team, there are some aspects of practice that he would not have implemented during his time as a youth boys' coach.
We call it a 'chatty warm-up," Kühn says. "For the first 10 or 15 minutes of practice, the girls are given some time to catch up with each other and talk about their days before we really get down to business."
From the fans’ perspective, though, a strong work ethic isn't quite enough to draw them into the stadium. The numbers show that most soccer fans in Germany are still more interested in the speed and aggression of the men's game than the technically sound and aesthetically pleasing women's game.
Average attendances at first league Bundesliga matches often reach well over 40,000, while in the women’s national league, organizers would be happy to see 4,000 fans pass through the turnstiles.